Beginner's Guide to Trading Card Grading

You've heard the term before: a PSA 10. A BGS 9.5. A CGC Pristine. But what does card grading actually mean — and should you care? This guide breaks it all down for beginners.

What Is Card Grading?

Card grading is the process of sending a trading card to a professional third-party company, which inspects the card's condition and assigns it a numeric grade — typically on a scale of 1 to 10. The card is then sealed in a tamper-evident plastic case (called a "slab") with the grade displayed on the label.

Graded cards offer collectors certainty: you know exactly what condition the card is in, and that condition has been verified by an independent expert.

The Major Grading Companies

There are several grading companies, but three dominate the market:

  • PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) — the most widely recognized brand; PSA-graded cards often command the highest premiums at auction
  • BGS (Beckett Grading Services) — known for subgrades (centering, corners, edges, surface), popular with serious collectors
  • CGC — originally a comic book grader that has expanded into trading cards with a growing reputation

How Cards Are Graded

Graders evaluate four key attributes of every card:

  • Centering — how evenly the printed image is centered within the card's borders
  • Corners — sharpness and wear on all four corners
  • Edges — condition of all four edges, checking for nicks or roughness
  • Surface — scratches, print defects, staining, or loss of gloss on front and back

A card that scores perfectly across all four categories earns a PSA 10 Gem Mint — the most coveted grade in the hobby.

Grade Scale Reference

  • 10 — Gem Mint: Perfect or near-perfect in every category
  • 9 — Mint: Minor imperfections only; still a strong grade
  • 8 — Near Mint-Mint: Light wear visible on close inspection
  • 7 — Near Mint: Minor flaws noticeable without a loupe
  • 6 and below: Visible wear, creases, or damage

Should You Grade Your Cards?

Grading makes the most sense when:

  • The card is valuable enough that a higher grade would meaningfully increase its worth
  • You plan to sell or auction the card and want buyer confidence
  • You're a long-term collector who wants a preserved, authenticated copy of a key card

For most budget cards (under $20–$30), grading fees may not be worth it. Save grading for your chase cards and personal favorites worth preserving.

Tips Before You Submit a Card for Grading

  • Handle cards by the edges only — fingerprints affect surface grades
  • Store in a penny sleeve and top loader immediately after pulling from a pack
  • Use a loupe or magnifier to self-inspect corners and centering before submitting
  • Research recent sales of the same card in similar grades to estimate ROI

Start With Cards in Great Condition

The best candidates for grading are cards you've kept in mint condition from the moment you acquired them. If you're buying singles with the intent to grade, shop from a source you trust — where cards are handled carefully and stored properly.

Browse our Pokémon Cards →

Have questions about a specific card you're thinking about grading? Come see us in store — we love talking cards.

Back to blog